Welcome or Register

About the Sold In The Keys Group

Joshua Mothner, Realtor

I am a licensed Realtor. I specialize in representing my clients in the purchase and sale of waterfront homes & condos, investment properties, boat slips, and commercial properties within Marathon and the Middle Keys. I truly love this area and pride myself on my knowledge of current transactions, school districts, neighborhood information, and related services, including the unique regulatory and insurance environment of the Florida Keys.

I am a customer driven Realtor dedicated to achieving results and providing exceptional service. I have sold, financed, listed, or developed over $140 million of Florida Keys Real Estate since 1998. If you are in the market to buy or sell a home, I will put my 15 years of real estate expertise to work for you!

  • REALTOR® certification
  • Coldwell Banker International President's Circle 2012
  • Graduate school of Banking at Louisiana State University
  • Honorably Discharged United State Army
  • Affilaite of the Year, Marathon and Lower Key Association of Realtors
  • Two Term President, Greater Marathon Chamber of Commerce
  • Treasurer and President, Middle Keys Community Land Trust
  • Appointed to City of Marathon Affordable Housing Task Force
  • Appointed to Monroe County Affordable Housing Task Force
  • Appointed to Monroe County Human Services Advisory Board Task Force


Rick Southwick

I am a licensed realtor.  I specialize in Buyer Services and Transaction Management.  My role is to make sure that all the little details of your transaction are handled smoothly and professionally. I have a long history in financial services which gives me an advantage to understanding the complex world of investing.

  • REALTOR® certification

Quick Search

view all



No Min.

No Max.


Josh Mothner did an excellent job for us from beginning to end. Most importantly he gave us a tremendous amount of his time without ever making us feel like we were imposing. Josh enabled us to find the property we were looking for in the Keys and guided us through the entire process. We highly recommend Josh for anyone looking to buy property in the Marathon area. Neal & Shari A.
Josh was attentive, knowledgeable, professional and particularly sensitive to the specific details of a very unusual transaction. He did a great job selling and administering the sale. Stan H.
View All